Nathan De Asha believes that if Nick Waker had competed at the 2024 Mr. Olympia – the top 2 would have been Samson Dauda and Walker
While the 2024 Mr. Olympia spotlight shone brightly on Samson Dauda, who clinched his first Men’s Open Bodybuilding title, the event also ignited discussions about those who could have made a difference on stage, especially Nick Walker. In a recent YouTube video posted on October 17, 2024, Open Pro competitor Nathan De Asha shared his perspective on the event’s outcome, including why he believed Nick Walker would have been the biggest threat to Samson Dauda if he didn’t withdraw.
Dauda’s Triumph Amidst Stiff Competition
Samson Dauda, known as “The Nigerian Lion,” made history with his 2024 Mr. Olympia win. He defeated strong contenders Hadi Choopan and Derek Lunsford, both former Olympia champions. Dauda’s victory was not without its share of risks and challenges. The season saw him make significant changes, including parting ways with his coach Milos Sarcev and leaving Kuwait’s renowned Oxygen Gym.
Adding to the uncertainty, Dauda competed just two weeks before the Olympia at a show in France, where he emerged victorious. This last-minute decision left fans concerned about whether he could peak again so soon for the Olympia.
Yet, Samson Dauda silenced his critics with a stunning display on the Olympia stage. He delivered a physique that showcased new levels of hardness and conditioning, which ultimately helped him stand out against the formidable competition.
Nathan De Asha commended Samson Dauda for his ability to adapt, acknowledging that Dauda took feedback from judges seriously.
“Samson was told to come in harder from his last show. He listened to what was said… He wasn’t the hardest, but he came in harder than he normally does,” De Asha noted.
What If Nick Walker Had Competed?
One of the major talking points of Nathan De Asha’s analysis was the absence of Nick Walker from this year’s Olympia stage. Walker, who has developed a significant fan following for his work ethic and impressive size, withdrew from the competition for the second consecutive year. He cited issues with his prep and a need to refine his physique before making another run at the title.
Nathan De Asha believes that if Nick Walker had been part of the lineup, the outcome of the competition might have been different.
“From what I’m looking at for me personally, if Nick Walker would have been in there, it would have been a battle between Nick Walker and Samson,” De Asha remarked.
He suggested that Walker’s withdrawal was a missed opportunity, as the conditions were ripe for a showdown between him and Dauda. Reflecting on Walker’s situation, De Asha said,
“If I was Nick I’d be absolutely heartbroken. Last year, you could’ve won it, and then this year, they give you a chance to where you had it.”
Nick Walker’s Next Move: The 2025 Arnold Classic or the Pittsburgh Pro?
Looking ahead, Nathan De Asha speculated on Nick Walker’s possible return to competition. He highlighted that if Walker decides to compete in the 2025 Arnold Classic, he could face backlash from fans.
“It would be good if he did [the Arnold Classic 2025], but you think he wouldn’t get a lot of backlash for it? I think he would,” De Asha said, pointing out that Walker’s recent decision to withdraw from the Olympia might put him under scrutiny.
Instead, Nathan De Asha suggested that Walker should consider the 2025 Pittsburgh Pro, which has recently expanded its Men’s Open division and increased prize money. He advised, “I would just leave it and go Pittsburgh.” By focusing on a smaller event, Nick Walker could refine his physique without the pressure that comes with a major competition like the Arnold Classic, while also avoiding the potential criticism that could come with a sudden comeback.
Dauda’s Next Challenge: Should He Compete at the Arnold Classic?
While fans are eager to see reigning Mr. Olympias participate in the Arnold Classic, Nathan De Asha expressed concern about Samson Dauda’s potential decision to compete in the 2025 edition.
“That’s why Mr. Olympias don’t really win the Olympia and then go to the Arnold. It gets judged differently… it should be the same criteria,” he commented.
De Asha emphasized the risks Dauda would face if he decided to jump into the Arnold Classic just months after his Olympia win.
However, De Asha acknowledged the allure of competing for another prestigious title and the lucrative prize money that comes with it.
“It’s good to be Olympia, but if I was Samson, I’d be thinking before December first should I go or shouldn’t I go… then again your confidence is riding high, you’re Mr. Olympia, it’s $500,000.”
The Future of Men’s Open Bodybuilding
With the 2024 Mr. Olympia wrapped up and new narratives unfolding, the bodybuilding world is already looking ahead to the next chapter. Nathan De Asha’s insights offer a glimpse into the shifting dynamics of the Men’s Open division, as well as the ongoing rivalries that continue to captivate fans. While De Asha believes that Choopan was a strong contender, he acknowledges that the sport remains unpredictable—especially with athletes like Dauda and Walker in the mix.
As the dust settles from this year’s Olympia, one thing is clear: the Men’s Open division remains as competitive as ever. With new challenges on the horizon, including the 2025 Arnold Classic and other upcoming shows, the battle for bodybuilding supremacy is far from over.
You can watch the full interview with Nathan De Asha here:
